zionism- Greenberg :: essays research papers

Response to Myth and MetaphorIt is not irrelevant nor is it fair to reply to the mirage of childish bickering that just frustrated the last half hour of my day without mentioning the more than obvious biases of the writers involved in their respective fields. Har aged Fisch, a prof of English Literature at Leeds University and soon after at Bar-Ilan University, writes a detailed analysis of what he refers to as the Myth and Metaphor of the various approaches to Zionism in his book titled The Zionist Revolution. In this analysis Fisch attempts to break down several approaches to the myth and metaphor of Zionism to give the reader a sense of broader companionship and a feeling that the field is generally covered in this article. He inevitably presents forth the opinion that he holds of highest regard last and most obviously, receivable to his literary nature, third in line after those of Aaron David Gordon and HaRav Avraham Yizchak Hakohen Kook respectively.The problem with Fischs analysis of Gordon and his metaphor of Zionism is that the passages that he selected to quote do not at all confine themselves to the commentary he addressed to them. In this selected passage Gordon speaks ofa life story organism which performs its various functions naturally..our natural soil from which we let been uprooted..The heart of our people is herefor here is the mainspring of our life..Here something is beginning to flowerHere is the force attracting all the scattered cells of the people to unite into one living national organism(pg. 56).Fischs misplaced claim comes directly following this quote when he claims that Gordon desires a kind of new religion to replace the old religion of Judaism. Fisch continues on the following page and claims that the religion he speaks of is one distinct from that of the Law and the prophets. From the biblical point of view we may say that we pass here a resurgence of something like the worship of the Bealim, the gods of the earth. From t he passage presented by Fisch we dont see any such existence. Gordon, like Rav Kook, and many another(prenominal) other contemporaries in this field, is devoted to the ideals of restoration to our roots and the mystical future that the Holy Land holds for its people when they will government issue to her. This concept is rattling much a part of the Jewish religion and can be seen in the well know verse Return to me and I will return to you, referring to G-ds promise to his people that he will return to them once they take the initiative to return to him.